The Braves' offseason overhaul is about to heat up—imagine the thrill of watching a championship contender reshape its squad right before our eyes. But here's where it gets controversial: are they willing to gamble on young talent or splash out on big-name veterans? Stick around as we dive deep into the possibilities unfolding at the Winter Meetings.
This piece is an excerpt from Mark Bowman's Braves Beat newsletter. For the complete newsletter, follow this link (https://links.mlb.mlbemail.com/s/vb/YtMXDHhieFrSvdShpWgALv8fSnMLCfELAgNN2Q8P9PnqEMal5NB-JbI3QcEilB6aVhH5rVLoJ0r3RX9cj88t9k8pwoGybCI3okc1Mb0VJBtibCFFURcWQ70WguA54T1y6simQITFTpMRGksMxi3RwZnSBKxhnumYRA/aragxaY2Y3H4jaJoy-QNt0pJULXieHrq/15). And why not sign up (https://www.mlb.com/fans/newsletters/beat-reporter) to have it delivered straight to your inbox regularly?
ATLANTA — As the Winter Meetings kick off Monday, the coming days and weeks promise to shed light on how the Braves will finalize their roster revamp for the offseason.
- Winter Meetings presented by CohnReznick: Full coverage awaits (https://www.mlb.com/news/topic/winter-meetings-coverage)
Braves president of baseball operations Alex Anthopoulos is set to chat with reporters Sunday evening, and once the Meetings officially start Monday at a Walt Disney World resort—right near the Braves' old Spring Training spot—the rumor mill will likely spin into overdrive.
MLB Network, MLB.com, and braves.com have you covered with comprehensive updates on all the action, wrapping up Wednesday.
Team Priorities: A starter pitcher, extra batting power, bullpen reinforcements, and possibly a shortstop
Dubón stands out as a versatile utility player who could handle everyday duties at shortstop. Opting for this path would free up more money for other team upgrades. After a year marred by numerous pitching injuries, the Braves would greatly benefit from bringing in a top-tier starter. For instance, fans are wondering if Reynaldo López will bounce back to his form before shoulder surgery, or if Grant Holmes can sidestep elbow surgery altogether. Adding a reliable ace could ease these rotation worries significantly.
The uncertainty around Joe Jiménez's knee surgery from last year opens the door for needing a high-stakes reliever to step in.
Key Debate: Will the Braves boost their lineup with another hitter?
The Braves must compensate for losing Marcell Ozuna's production in the designated hitter spot. Even if they sign shortstop Ha-Seong Kim and relegate Dubón to utility roles, many argue the batting order still lacks depth. Choosing a full-time DH might limit playing time for young catcher Drake Baldwin, but bringing in an outfielder could provide flexibility, as they'd be a strong option to fill the DH role among others.
Atlanta's offense looks set for improvement with Ronald Acuña Jr., Austin Riley, and Ozzie Albies returning healthier than they were early in the 2025 season. That said, a lot remains uncertain as the team relies on their well-being and hopes for extended strong performances from Jurickson Profar and Michael Harris II beyond just a few months. So, bolstering the lineup with one more hitter seems like a smart move overall.
And this is the part most people miss: In a sport where injuries can derail even the best plans, is it wiser to invest in proven talent now or bet on health and youth? Some fans might argue that adding a bat is essential for contending, while others could see it as overkill, potentially blocking younger players' development.
Possible Trades in the Mix
Sean Murphy's name has come up in talks, though there's no sign the Braves are eager to part with the experienced catcher. If they did, they'd likely get limited value until the 2023 All-Star fully recovers from hip surgery. Yet, Murphy and Baldwin could form one of baseball's premier catching tandems if the veteran gets back to full strength.
While safeguarding pitching depth is important, the progress made by prospects like JR Ritchie (ATL's No. 2 prospect (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/braves/jr-ritchie-702275)/No. 86 overall (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/top100/jr-ritchie-702275)) and Hurston Waldrep last season has bolstered the organization's pitching reserves. This doesn't mean trading top talents like Cam Caminiti (ATL's No. 1 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/braves/cam-caminiti-807284)/MLB's No. 72 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/top100/cam-caminiti-807284)) or Didier Fuentes (ATL's No. 7 (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/braves/didier-fuentes-800311)) is advisable, but the Braves would be negotiating from a solid foundation of depth.
But here's where it gets controversial: Trading prospects like these is a hot-button issue. On one hand, it could secure immediate wins; on the other, it might sacrifice long-term potential. What do you think—should the Braves prioritize the present or the future?
Prospect Spotlight
Ritchie achieved a 2.64 ERA across 26 starts spanning three levels in 2025. The 22-year-old right-hander kicked off the year in High-A and wrapped up with a 3.02 ERA in 11 Triple-A outings. That's impressive, especially as his first unrestricted season post-Tommy John surgery. As the 35th overall pick from the 2022 Draft, he might soon crack into Atlanta's starting rotation for 2026.
To beginners, Tommy John surgery is a procedure to repair a torn elbow ligament, common among pitchers, and recovery can take a year or more—Ritchie's comeback shows the resilience needed in the pros.
Rule 5 Draft Insights
Last year, the Braves selected two players in the MLB Rule 5 Draft: right-hander Anderson Pilar and infielder Christian Cairo, but both were returned to their original teams before Spring Training ended.
If the Braves forfeit a player in this year's Rule 5 Draft, it might be their No. 11 prospect (https://www.mlb.com/milb/prospects/braves/blake-burkhalter-686628), Blake Burkhalter.
Atlanta chose not to expand its 40-man roster before the Rule 5 deadline, keeping Burkhalter and others in play. The 6-foot right-hander excelled as a Double-A starter in 2025 before shifting to the Triple-A bullpen, though he struck out fewer batters there (23 Ks in 31 innings). His fastball, clocking 92-95 mph with notable lift (averaging 17.9 inches of induced vertical break at Triple-A) and some cut, plus a true cutter in the upper-80s, a low-80s curve for right-handed hitters, and a mid-80s changeup for lefties, could appeal to Rule 5 teams.
For those new to baseball, the Rule 5 Draft is an annual event where teams can pick unprotected minor leaguers from other organizations to add to their rosters, often spotlighting hidden gems or potential breakouts.
So, as the Braves navigate these decisions, we're left wondering: Is trading away prospects a necessary evil for short-term success, or does it risk the franchise's future? Do you agree that adding another hitter is non-negotiable, or should they trust in their young core? Share your thoughts in the comments—let's debate!
