Islam Makhachev: The GOAT Debate After UFC 322 Win! (2025)

Imagine a fighter so dominant that a single victory could catapult him into the pantheon of MMA legends—Islam Makhachev is on the brink of that reality. As UFC 322 approaches, Michael Bisping, the legendary UFC Hall of Famer and insightful commentator, believes a win for Makhachev could irrevocably cement his legacy among the sport's greatest ever. But here's where it gets intriguing: what if this underdog leap into welterweight not only redefines Makhachev's career but also sparks debates about who truly deserves the top spot on the GOAT list? Let's dive into the details and unpack why this fight matters so much.

Islam Makhachev steps into the octagon at UFC 322 with a golden chance to achieve something truly extraordinary. Facing off against welterweight champion Jack Della Maddalena in the main event at the iconic Madison Square Garden in New York City, Makhachev (boasting a 27-1 MMA record, including 16-1 in the UFC) is making his move up from lightweight after relinquishing his title following an impressive string of defenses. The event streams live on ESPN+ pay-per-view, with additional coverage on ESPNews, FX, Disney+, and ESPN+. For those new to the sport, Makhachev's decision to vacate the lightweight belt shows his strategic vision—by stepping away after amassing those defenses, he's positioning himself for bigger challenges, much like a chess player sacrificing a piece to control the board.

A victory wouldn't just hand him the welterweight crown; it would mark Makhachev as the 11th fighter in UFC history to claim titles across two divisions, and more crucially, it would match Anderson Silva's record for the longest unbroken winning streak in the promotion's history at 16 straight wins. To put that in perspective, Anderson Silva, often called "The Spider," dominated the middleweight scene for years with his unorthodox striking and submissions, turning opponents into highlights rather than contenders. If Makhachev pulls this off, it's fair to argue his resume could stand shoulder-to-shoulder with MMA immortals like Jon Jones—the enigmatic talent with bone-crunching knockouts—Georges St-Pierre, the tactical mastermind who ruled lightweight, Anderson Silva himself, and Demetrious Johnson, the flyweight wizard known for his speed and precision. These are names etched in UFC lore, fighters whose careers set the standard for greatness.

Michael Bisping, never one to mince words, concedes that breaking into this elite group is no small feat. "It doesn't sound right," he shared with MMA Junkie, "Maybe I'm not giving him his credit there." Bisping points out the differences: Anderson Silva claimed his UFC crown just two fights in, dispatching Chris Leben and Rich Franklin, then stacking up most of his wins as title defenses. Jon Jones and Georges St-Pierre followed a similar path, racking up belts through multiple reigns. This highlights a key point for beginners: title defenses often carry more weight because they come against progressively tougher opponents, unlike early career wins against less-established fighters. Yet, Bisping is quick to add, "I'm certainly not critiquing Islam Makhachev's career. I'm not nit-picking or discrediting it at all. ... If he gets the job done, I think without question he deserves to be in that conversation." It's a balanced view—acknowledging the hurdles while praising the potential.

And this is the part most people miss: for Bisping's personal hierarchy, a triumphant Makhachev, at 34 years old, might just edge into that top tier. The Dagestani star isn't far off already, especially as the No. 2 in the latest USA TODAY Sports/MMA Junkie pound-for-pound rankings. He's already proven his mettle with relentless training from Dagestan, a region famous for producing world-class grapplers and fighters, blending striking, wrestling, and submissions into a lethal package.

But let's talk about the welterweight division, where things heat up significantly. Often called the "glory weight," 170 pounds is packed with talent more than ever before. Beyond UFC 322's headliner, the card includes exciting bouts like Sean Brady versus Michael Morales, and Leon Edwards taking on Carlos Prates. The following week at UFC Fight Night 265 in Qatar, we'll see Belal Muhammad, a former champ, clash with rising star Ian Machado Garry. Don't forget Kamaru Usman, the former kingpin eyeing one last title run before retirement, or Shavkat Rakhmonov, the undefeated powerhouse recovering from setbacks and hungry to assert his dominance. If Makhachev secures that gold at UFC 322, he'll face a gauntlet of fresh challenges—perhaps the toughest of his career yet. And if he can defend it multiple times against these heavyweights, Bisping predicts a seismic shift: "Without a shadow of a doubt," he said. "If he beat Jack – and it's a big if – if he can beat Jack and go on a run and defend it two or three times, it's insane." Imagine Makhachev evolving from a division-jumper to the undisputed No. 1—could he surpass even Jones or GSP in your eyes?

Here's the controversy: Is Makhachev's path to GOAT status fair, especially compared to those who built legacies in one weight class? Or does transcending divisions make him even more remarkable, like a modern-day Conor McGregor? What do you think—does a win here elevate him to legendary status, or are we overhyped by the streak? Share your thoughts in the comments: agree or disagree, and let's debate who the real GOATs are in MMA today!

Islam Makhachev: The GOAT Debate After UFC 322 Win! (2025)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Mrs. Angelic Larkin

Last Updated:

Views: 6548

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Mrs. Angelic Larkin

Birthday: 1992-06-28

Address: Apt. 413 8275 Mueller Overpass, South Magnolia, IA 99527-6023

Phone: +6824704719725

Job: District Real-Estate Facilitator

Hobby: Letterboxing, Vacation, Poi, Homebrewing, Mountain biking, Slacklining, Cabaret

Introduction: My name is Mrs. Angelic Larkin, I am a cute, charming, funny, determined, inexpensive, joyous, cheerful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.